If you haven’t yet, at some point in life you’ll look around and ask yourself, “How did I get so much stuff?” A trinket here, a souvenir there, a thing you really didn’t have a use for but you never know so you put it down in the basement but never actually touch it or look at it again. These things pile up. Add kids to the mix and that amount of stuff multiplies quickly. A vast majority of stuff kids use is not long for this world. A good amount is just junk they never needed in the first place, but even the best stuff, their at one point in time favorite stuff, is inevitably outgrown. Possessions, whether once prized or or immediately discarded, are temporary. Despite their inherent transient nature they seem to have a habit of establishing squatters rights in your basement or garage. One of the more satisfying things I’ve done recently is get a dumpster and evict them.
This summer while the kids were having a long weekend at Grandpa’s, my wife and I really lived it up without the kids. We cleaned. While me from ten years ago would be so disappointed in present me, present me was equally disappointed in me from 10, 15, and 20 years ago for not just throwing away their crap at the time. Sure, past versions of me had their reasons for hanging on to whatever it was they decided to keep. Most of them came down to a memory. A keepsake of an event or a reminder of a specific time in life. Who wouldn’t want to hang on to something to help immortalize a key memory? The problem is two-fold.
We Can’t Tell What Is Really Important
First, we are really bad judges of what is important enough to keep. In the moment, saving every ticket stub to every movie or baseball game I ever went to seemed like a neat idea, a fun keepsake that I could look back on later and say “Hey, remember when you went to see the Tigers play Cleveland in 1997?” And yes, I do remember that. And the memory of me lustily booing Albert Belle is fond memory indeed. Then I threw my giant pile of ticket stubs away, and wouldn’t you know it, I still remembered it. Was it a fun time? Absolutely. Was it important enough to justify keeping a tiny scrap of paper tucked away in a box in my basement for the last 30 years? Absolutely not.
And neither was almost everything I had stored up and taking up space. Cardboard boxes and Rubbermaid bins full of stuff that seemed at least moderately important enough to keep at the time all meet the same fate. The bottom of a dumpster. The stuff that really mattered enough to keep didn’t take up much space at all. Actually just one locked box with stuff like birth certificates, marriage license, the mountain of paperwork I got when we bought our house that I never really read or understood but assume I need to prove I own my house. That’s about it. Everything else could go, since it’s only value was that it was in some way connected to a memory.

While it was easy to realize I didn’t need to keep a giant over-sized novelty penny to help me remember my 8th grade field trip to Washington DC, I have to admit it gets much harder to determine what is important enough to keep once stuff from my kids comes into play. On one hand, I fully understand that their worksheet on how to write the letter B is not as important as a card they made me for Fathers Day (which is definitely a day worth creating some core memories around). But on the other hand – look how cute they made their little Bs! And the stick figure self-portrait they made, might as well get that piece of trash Mona Lisa out of the way to make room in the Louvre. You can see my dilemma, I’m sure.
What makes it hard with getting rid of your kids’ stuff is that they aren’t attached to a memory the same way an old t-shirt is. Most of the stuff you decided to hang on to was associated to an event – a vacation, a football game, a high school dance. But your kids’ old toys aren’t attached to the memory of a time they played with the toy, they are attached to the person they were when they played with the toy. And that is what you want to hang on to forever. My oldest daughter is about to start middle school, so while I don’t need to keep coloring sheets she did in pre-school, I wouldn’t mind storing that pre-school version of her somewhere safely locked away. Sealed somewhere in a waterproof airtight container like a mint condition baseball card. Actually, that is a bad example, because I threw away my baseball cards too. I had to face the fact that my Chris Gomez rookie card didn’t turn out to be a lotto ticket I can cash in. So let’s say frozen in time, so that I could thaw her out like Encino Man and pick her up and throw her in the air a few more times. For all the times your kids ask you pick them up and get annoyed by it, remember this, there will come a day when they stop asking, but even worse, there will come a day when you just can’t.
Which brings me to my second reason why connecting physical stuff to memories in hopes it will last forever is waste. I hate to break this to you, but nothing lasts forever. Neither cold November rain nor the youth of children. Or also perhaps Guns ‘N Roses references? Hopefully at least one person reading this picked up what I put down.
Your Memories Die With You
All physical stuff is inherently impermanent. It falls apart, it fades, it decays. I know you may love it now, but the odds of a future civilization unearthing your sticker covered Owala bottle and thinking it was of any importance are extremely slim. Even if those stickers remind you of that time you went to place and did that thing, I promise you it will be lost in a meaningless heap of trash sooner or later. So you might as well be the one to put it there rather than make your kids figure out what to do with it after you die.
Because people aren’t permanent either. My stuff may have meant something to me, and I’m sure you have stuff that feels special to you, but to quote George Carlin – have you noticed that their stuff is shit and your shit is stuff? My memories are mine and yours are yours, and they are likely not the same. The coconut pirate head that I have on my desk reminds me of the Pirates of the Caribbean ride and trips to Disney World as a kid. And that is fun for me. But will it have any special association with for my kids? Let’s say I never throw it away and after I die my kids find it in a box. Are they going to have any special attachment to a thing from a vacation they didn’t take or sat on a desk that wasn’t theirs? Or are they going to wonder why I saved a creepy looking pirate head? They can’t ask me, I’ll be dead. If they throw it away, it can’t possibly hurt my feelings, I’ll be dead. I can’t put memories in a will, so the best thing I could pass down to my kids is an absence of crap they’ll have to go through.
So I’ll hang on to the memories, but let go of the stuff. I’ll make more of an effort to create memorable experiences. And also be present in those experiences so I absorb it all and lock it away somewhere in my brain for later use. It may not be fun, but if you do chose to buy stuff to commemorate occasions, I highly recommend buying extremely practical souvenirs. I regret not bringing home a spatula from our trip to Hawaii. We’d absolutely get our use out of it, and some day years from on cold morning I could make myself a hot stack of pancakes and be transported in my mind back to eating pancakes by the beach, even if outside there is a cold November rain.












